A wood shake roof should be evaluated on its condition and repair needs. Age or material alone does not establish that the entire roof must be replaced. An inspection can identify damaged areas and help you compare localized repairs with a broader replacement.
Review the condition of the assembly
Ask about the shakes, flashing, roof penetrations, and any signs of water entry. Document earlier repairs and recurring problems. The recommendation should explain what remains serviceable and where repair is limited by deterioration or material availability.
Compare replacement options carefully
If replacement is appropriate, compare wood, composite shake, asphalt shingles, or other suitable systems for appearance, installation requirements, maintenance, and written warranties. Review actual samples and the exact product specifications instead of assuming all products in a material category perform alike.
Verify ratings and insurance terms
Ask for fire and impact ratings for the proposed roof assembly, including required installation components. Check any insurance eligibility or premium change directly with your insurer before purchasing. Do not assume that replacing wood shakes guarantees a discount or that every alternative carries the same rating.
Plan the scope
Discuss tear-off, decking allowances, flashing, ventilation, and disposal in the estimate. Review roof replacement planning or request an inspection of your existing shake roof.
Article photos
